Showing posts with label Moral Hazard. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Moral Hazard. Show all posts
April 18, 2010

An Open Letter to Mr. Rooney: Crime and Punishment and the Steelers

Pittsburgh Steelers, Ben Roethlistberger

A law is a rule that society accepts and agrees to be bound by. The basic argument is laid out in Hobbes' Social Contract theory, which holds that people trade constraints on their own action in return for the opportunity to live in a safer, regulated society - a civilized society. When people break the law, it's a crime against both the victim and the civil system.

When USAir cancelled the retirement system for thousands of employee's, was it a crime? Apparently not, since it was done within the laws - in fact, it was facilitated by the laws.

This brings us to the concept of natural law, which posits the existence of a law set by nature and which has validity everywhere. When the authors of the United States Consitution declared "we hold these rights to be self-evident", they were invoking natural law.

Was USAir cancelling the retirement system for thousands of employees a crime in natural law? Yes, I think so. They bargained and agreed to future benefits in exchange for work now, and when the work was done and the cost inconvenient they broke their word in a case of temporal arbitrage. In a more refined era of social clarity, the Board and Management would be shunned and excommunicated from civil society.

We don't often shame people anymore, and we seem to increasingly say "if you're not convicted, you're all right - who am I to judge?", which is a subjugation of morality to legalism.

When a legal crime is committed, our legal system calls for punishment. Why punishment? To stigmatize the undesirable behavior, to demonstrate the dominance of the law, to deter others considering the same behavior, and to restore a modicum of justice to the victim(s), all of which serve to perpetuate the system.

When the crime does not rise to the legal standard but offends natural law, propriety and the social conscience, we should support a social punishment - disapproval, disavowal, condemnation, censure, separation - for all the same reasons. It doesn't have to be a legal crime to be unacceptable.

Sometimes a transgression is forgiven. Forgiveness is a moral action based on moral considerations. Increasingly, forgiveness and even absolution are becoming utilitarian judgments rather than moral judgments. It's a fallacy to conflate moral judgment with utilitarian calculation.

Talking heads tell us that some organizations and people are "too big to fail" (TBTF), or in other words too big to be held responsible for their actions. Bank of America, General Motors, and Fannie Mae were all too big to be left to accountability. When people know they're unlikely to be held accountable, the situation is called "moral hazard", which we've written about before in this space.

steelers roethlisbergerMoral Hazard is the situation in which decisions are disconnected from, and even insulated from, accountability. Moral hazard results in reckless, bad decision making, the costs of which are borne by others.

What do you do when you're the boss, and a key subordinate acts unacceptably - not once, but a few times? What do you do when you're the judge, and a public figure acts unacceptably? Does the importance of the individual matter? Are you less likely to punish a wealthy, important, popular person than an entry-level unknown? Does utility bear on morality?

So, Mr. Rooney, here's a rhetorical question. You're the Bishop. One of your Priests has been outside the limits, more than once. There's been stories but they were all in-house. Now there's been two public events. The individual is a key player. If left in position, the individual may do important business and bring a lot of people to salvation. Priests are hard to come by. Do you:
  • Suspend the Priest for six months, send him to counseling, and then return him to his previous assignment?
  • Fire the Priest, remove them from the organization, and reinforce the moral standards of the brand?
Your answer would be of interest to parents of school children everywhere.

Fortunately, Mr. Rooney, you've got an easier question. You run an entertainment franchise that showcases athletes. The individual is a key player who brings in a lot of people. Do you:
  • Suspend the player for two months and return him to duty?
  • Fire the player, accept the loss of results, and reinforce the standards of the brand?
Does another winning season matter so much?
Is a young woman worth a Super Bowl? How many would be too many?
How would you treat it if he were the janitor? Or a wide receiver?

Your answer will be of interest to parents of 20-year old girls, and to parents of 14-year old football players, everywhere.
December 28, 2008

The Dukes of Moral Hazard

Decisions and actions generally have consequences- good decisions and good actions generally yield good consequences, bad decisions and bad actions generally yield bad consequences. That's what we try to teach our kids.

But Sometimes, decisions and actions become insulated from consequences. Sometimes that's a retroactive implication, and sometimes there's a future implication.

Here's an exaggerated example: the North Carolina realtor tells a client: Sure you can build a beach house right on the dunes, the federal government will reimburse you when it gets washed away every three years. Or another: when a social program tells the welfare queen that she'll get increased benefits and a bigger place if she has another kid. Either case, when risk is subsidized, risky behavior is more likely to occur.


The lack of connection between decisions/actions and consequences is called Moral Hazard. The phrase comes out of economics and the insurance industry, and the memo goes like this: if you protect somebody too well from likely outcomes, then they will act differently, probably in a manner that would be ordinarily considered irresponsible.

Although it sounds like something a preacher would say, there's no moral critique or condemnation of behavior; the term moral hazard strictly refers to behavior in the face of artificially relieved or subsidized risk.


Generally, we're talking about government guarantees. Some government programs are good things: we want recently unemployed people to have a safety net. If there were no risk involved in not returning to work, we'd have moral hazard. Often, moral hazard occurs when a well-intentioned, altruistic goverment program extends beyond the initial scope to become a counter-productive anti-pattern.

There are interesting social and economic responses to moral hazard, summed up in those three little words: "I want mine". When I find out that my neighbor is immune from consequences, I think I'd also like to be immunized. If he can have some, I want some. This certainly skews the notion of government of the people and turns Uncle Sam into Big Daddy with Special Dispensations.

So General Motors is in trouble. Ford is in trouble. Some people want to bail them out, because there's a lot of jobs at stake, there's politics involved, and anyway - they're too big to be permitted to fail, the spokesmen tell us. And somehow the Government is going to take $2000 from you and your kids (which you've made, presumably, with good decisions and actions) and give it to those Corporations and businessmen who made bad decisions.

This of course, increases competitive pressure on the carmakers who were making good decisions all along, and who aren't angling for your $2000. Toyota calls "foul!", but we don't know what to do about that.

Wall Street is in trouble, too. They just got $700B of your money because they made bad decisions. I don't remember getting any of theirs when they made good decisions.

Thomas Friedman says "the only question will be, is it being done for you or to you?" Will this transfer of funds change Detroit/Wall Street's future behavior, or just delay the inevitable reckoning (with your money?) Friedman also suggests these CEOs shouldn't be looking for a bailout, they should be looking for bail.

Where's the bailout for the 250 Fore/Marconi/Ericcson employees?
Where was the bailout for the USAirways retirees and employees?
Where was the bailout for the steel mills?
Have you ever seen a corporation bail out a town?
Have you ever seen a casino bail out a loser?