Showing posts with label Great Allegheny Passage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Great Allegheny Passage. Show all posts
December 22, 2011

Zeno's Arrow, the GAP Trail and the Speed of Christmas

Once upon a time there was a Greek guy named Zeno of Elea. Some pretentious people were making ridiculous arguments wrapped in very fancy structures and speeches and he wanted to show them they were being silly, so he took their thinking to its logical conclusion and described the problem of an arrow reaching its target.

So you've got the archer at distance=0, and the target at distance=100 feet. (We'll use feet because we're Americans and we don't like the metric system.) The archer wants the arrow to hit the target so she aims, draws the bowstring, and lets loose.



An unsophisticated person might think the arrow would fly to the target, but Zeno explained that if one was to follow his colleague's arguments, before the arrow could get to the target it would have to reach the halfway point (50 feet). And so, at some intermediate point the arrow is halfway there.

But then, before the arrow can go the rest of the way, it has to go with the halfway thing again. So at another intermediate point, the arrow is at 75 feet.

Almost there, right? But no, before it can hit the target it has to reach halfway, 87.5 feet.And again and again and again: 93.75 feet, 96.975 feet, 98.4875 feet, all of a sudden these numbers look like the damned metric system. The absurdity is, Zeno explains, that at any moment there's always a halfway distance to be reached first, and so truly reaching the destination is logically impossible.

Big silence; dead air. Zeno reformatted the story in terms of walking across the room, and explained why you could move most of the way across the room but you could never really get there, if you followed their thinking. The legend says that Diogenes, who was getting tired of the exercise, then walked across the room and sat down, rolling his eyes at to Zeno to show that he understood the fallacy in a way that was lost to the others.

It seems like an esoteric paradox that might have been amusing a few centuries ago, but we have better things to consider these days (like figuring out how many wars we're in) except that it keeps popping up.


The progress of the Great Allegheny Passage also seems to follow Zeno's Paradox. Each year, half of the remaining trail between Pittsburgh and DC is completed and introduced; each year the gaps are reduced, and yet in spite of the incremental progress it seems like true completion is never achieved.



Or say you're driving to Grandma's with your kids in the back seat. Are we there yet? No. Are we there yet? No. Are we there yet? No. Are we there yet? No. Are we there yet? No. Are we there yet? No. Are we there yet? No.

It may be that Zeno just figured out quantum theory before his time. If you're comfortable with location as a probability distribution rather than a fixed certainty, you're probably good with Zeno's arrow eventually being mostly there.

Today's XKCD works the same theme:




We are grateful for the XKCD-symbiotic website, Explain XKCD.com which draws out the cleverness of the work. Today they point out the nuanced fallacy of Zeno having an Advent calendar because he lived B.C.


Merry Christmas. I hope it gets here, and/or that we get there.
June 05, 2011

New GAP Bike Trail Duquesne to Waterfront



Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/GAPTrail
Yahoo: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Montour-Trail/message/4288

PLEASE JOIN US TO CELEBRATE!
The opening of the newest section of the Great Allegheny Passage. Friday, June 17, 2011 at 10:00 am.

The amazing 3-mile section of the Passage includes two new bridges, a rolling ride along the scenic former U. S. Steel coke gas pipeline, and an exciting view of two of Kennywood's Coasters.

There will be an brief ceremony at the Whitaker Bridge to thank the funders, landowners, contractors, and volunteers. Bring your bicycle and ride the new section after the event.

RSVP to admin@atatrail.org or call 724-537-6905.

DIRECTIONS: Please enter at Guardian Storage (1002 East Waterfront Dr. Munhall, PA 15120) and you will be directed to parking for the event.




The new trail section is depicted in bright green in this hacked map:


  • Note that the Sandcastle segment (due to open 11/11/11) is the remaining significant barrier to DC riders getting to downtown
  • Notice how the Montour Trail is poised to connect to the Pittsburgh-to-DC Great Allegheny Passage
  • Observe how the Panhandle Trail is poised to develop into an Oakdale-to-Oakland trail
  • After Sandcastle, the remaining last bit of unfinished trail will be connecting Point State Park, the Mon Whorf Trail, and the upper level of the Smithfield Street Bridge for access to the Jail Trail








A report of an overnight Pittsburgh bike trip from this last week, West Newton to Rockwood and back.
July 13, 2010

Great News for Pittsburgh Bike Trails

The last week has brought remarkably good news for Pittsburgh bike trails.

Two New Trail Bridges at Duquesne and Whitaker

By John Schmitz in the Post-Gazette on July 8th: County bridges all gaps but one in Pittsburgh-to-D.C. trail. Two new bike bridges have been placed across railroad tracks in Whitaker and Duquesne, PA.

The 170-foot bridge near Whitaker, which will have a 350-foot access ramp, will cross the tracks between Kennywood Park and the Rankin Bridge. The 137-foot bridge near Duquesne will have two 350-foot access ramps. The total cost of the bridge project is $3.5 million.

This will permit completion of the trail from the current terminus on Grant Street in Duguesne, beyond Kennywood, and connecting to the Waterfront Trail (which in turn leads to Sandcastle).

All that will remain incomplete on the Great Allegheny Passage after that is a one-mile stretch through Sandcastle Waterpark. Negotiations with the park owners have not produced an agreement that will allow the trail to go through.

"There's no solution just yet," Allegheny County spokesman Kevin Evanto said. "We're kind of at the same place we were a couple months ago."


Agreement Reached on Sandcastle Bike Trail

First seen at Pgh is a City, the Post Gazette's John Schmitz writes on July 13th:
Allegheny County and Sandcastle Waterpark are expected to announce an agreement within days that will allow completion of the last missing piece of a biking and hiking trail linking Pittsburgh and Washington, D.C.

"I really expect we'll have a formal announcement in the next couple days," said James Judy, vice president of operations for Palace Entertainment, owner of the park.

"I believe that is probably going to be the case," agreed county spokesman Kevin Evanto.



The combination of the two bridges and the Sandcastle agreement means that riding from downtown Pittsburgh to the main trail in Duquesne will no longer be a questionable, frightening act of courage along Route 837. It's going to be a ride you can take your children on and not be concerned about getting them killed. This is huge.

Amtrak Bike Service, Pittsburgh to DC, June '11

Posted in a message in the GAP Yahoo Group was an email message from Linda McKenna Boxx, President of the Allegheny Trail Alliance:
Yesterday at a meeting in Harrisburg, Amtrak officials announced that they would begin offering roll-on/roll-off bicycle service on the Capitol Limited by the end of June 2011!

This means that cyclists boarding at Pittsburgh, Connellsville, Cumberland, Harpers Ferry, Martinsburg, Rockville, or Washington, DC will be able to roll their bikes onto the train (reservations will be required; spaces will be limited at first), put them in a rack, and get off at any of these stops. Amtrak will be retrofitting several cars and needs to work out operational issues before the service can begin.

This is great news for all the towns along the Great Allegheny Passage and the C&O Canal towpath. This will add a great convenience and extra excitement to tourists who want to bike our great trail system.


This Amtrak announcement solves the logistical problem of making the round-trip without riding 700 miles; how do you get you, your bike, and your gear home after the bike ride? Now, if you're in Pittsburgh you can take the train to DC, disembark with your bike and start riding on the trail. Or, ride the trail from Pittsburgh to DC (my preferred direction), stay in the hostel and get on the next train to Pittsburgh.

My compliments to all involved.
June 01, 2010

DC - Pittsburgh Bike Trip: Distance and Elevation Chart

Compiled from a few reliable sources, here's a table of distances (in miles) and elevation (in feet above Mean Sea Level) riding from Washington, DC to Cumberland, MD via the C&O Canal, then continuing from Cumberland MD to Pittsburgh, PA via the Great Allegheny Passage.


   Miles  elev 'MSL
Georgetown  0  72
Great Falls  14  140
White's Ferry  35  213
Point of Rocks  48  233
Brunswick  55  246
Harper's Ferry  59  299
Shepherdstown  73  322
Wiliamsport  99  380
Hancock  124  446
Little Orleans  141  502
PawPaw  151  492
OldTown  161  568
Cumberland  184  610
Frostburg  200  1801
Meyersdale  216  2416
Garrett  221  1916
Rockwood  228  1801
Confluence  246  1340
Ohiopyle  258  1230
Connellsville  272  856
Perryopolis  287  797
Smithton  292  771
West Newton  298  761
Buena Vista  305  787
Boston  312  745
McKeesport  316  750
Point State Park 334  720


Which produces an elevation profile that looks something like this:

The elevation profile isn't perfectly accurate (it relies on a approximation of an altimeter) but it serves to give an idea of the relative slope, eastbound versus westbound, at the Eastern Continental Divide.

This is a chart that can easily mislead; the horizontal scale is 350 miles, while the vertical scale is 1/2 of a mile.
May 20, 2010

Boston - McKeesport - Duquesne PA Bike Trail

I had the opportunity today to ride from West Newton, PA to Duquesne PA round trip along the Great Allegheny Passage. It was really a nice day, there were a lot of people on the trail.



The last few times I rode this, I departed the Great Allegheny Passage at the Versailles bridge, and took a kludge of backstreets, alleys, and a paved trail winding through an industrial park to get to McKees Marina. This time I stayed on the GAP at Elizabeth Township, road through Boston, climbed the hill at the Durabond Bypass, and then entered McKeesport at midtown. This was a much better transition through the area and up to McKees Marina.

The real treat was that I got to ride the new sections of trail in McKeesport and Duquesne. Starting at the trailhead at McKees Marina, I took Fifth and Locust streets to the new trail. The new trail is paved and fenced, and leads to an awesome refurbished trail bridge across the river. On the other side, the trail is paved and ends at Grant Street in Duquesne, where you can pick up Route 837 for the road ride to SouthSide Works.

The new trail segments and the bridge are excellent, and if the quality of these new sections is repeated as the Duquesne-SandCastle gap is closed it'll be a remarkable accomplishment.

May 02, 2010

DC to Pittsburgh Bike Trip

It's the time of year to consider such things.

Here's a video from 2008's Adventure Cycling tour from DC to Pittsburgh. Out of the several video's online, I think it does the best of presenting trail conditions on both the C&O Canal Trail (DC to Cumberland) and the Great Allegheny Passage (Cumberland to Pittsburgh).


A few notes: most of the video is shot from a recumbent bike, that's why you'll see shoes pumping up and down. These folks are camping; hotels are also an option. At the end of the video you'll see the riders; I'd like to point out that none of them are young triathletes (NTTAWWT).

Pittsburghers Sam and Jane Menchyk are scheduled to begin their 7-day bike ride from Washington DC to near Pittsburgh on May 29th. Their website contains pictures and reports from previous rides (this is their third time) and contains a lot of valuable information. Sam makes really great infographics, weaving geography and schedules into intuitive images. If you're considering such a trip, it's worth a look.
March 11, 2010

Google Bike Maps - Pittsburgh to Boston Trailhead

Google has announced that their Google Maps application now attempts to provide bike routes. The routing algorithm prefers to use bike paths, lanes, and sharrows, and attempts to avoid hills and highways.

This is great. I asked it for a route from Pittsburgh PA to Washington DC and it routed me via the Great Allegheny Passage and the C&O Canal.
Google bike map, Pittsburgh to DC

Among bicyclists familiar with riding from Pittsburgh to DC, perhaps no other topic is as continually energetic as, "What is the best way to get from The Point to the trail in McKeesport-Boston?"
  • There is the Ft Pitt bridge, Station Square to Baldwin Trail, ~andcastle, and then 837 past Kennywood to the West Mifflin trailhead group.
    • There's a Jail Trail, Hot Metal Bridge, Baldwin Trail variation.
  • There is the Second Avenue, Glenwood Bridge, 885 to 837, Kennywood, West Mifflin contingent.
  • Finally, there's the schism group that believes it's irresponsible to advise any transient cyclist to ride north of Boston. (that's my denomination)
This discussion generates more passion than Helmet Wars and even the Recumbent Question. I thought it would be interesting to see which path Google picked from the Point to the trail in McKeesport or Boston. It choose this:
bike map, Pittsburgh Point to McKeesport or Boston bike trail

This is intriguing - Google choose the Second Avenue route out of downtown, followed by an unexpected direct (and hilly) route from the Glenwood Bridge to Boston PA. It works, and it's lower traffic than 837, but it'd be a lot of work on a bike loaded with panniers.

My review of Google Bike Maps: It's not as good as knowledge of the local area, but if you're unfamiliar and trying to plot a route it'll be a worthwhile tool. It would be wonderful if you could export the Google route into a Garmin GPS for on-bike navigation, but I realize that they're selling 'Droid phones so the GPS export probably isn't likely.

Update (courtesy of Mike from the GAP Yahoo Group): there's a third-party Google-Maps to GPX exporter at: http://www.elsewhere.org/journal/gmaptogpx/.

October 17, 2009

Google Trike Suggestion: Great Allegheny Passage

I've previously written about the Google Trike using StreetView technology to present bike trail images in Google Maps. Now, Google is soliciting suggestions (until October 28th) about where the Google Trike should go next.

If you'll click https://services.google.com/fb/forms/streetviewussuggestions/, you'll see Google's solicitation of the next area for the Google Trike to map.

I'd like to respectfully request that you click that link, and suggest that the Google Trike goes to:
Category: Trail
Suggestion: Great Allegheny Passage
City: Pittsburgh and Cumberland
State: PA and MD
This would encourage tourism in the Pittsburgh-DC corridor and give more national visibility to a positive Pittsburgh attribute.
Kudos to: Paul Wiegman for passing this around.
October 10, 2009

Pittsburgh, the Copenhagen of Appalachia



Excellent article in USAToday proclaiming the Great Allegheny Passage as a Recession-Proof Getaway, complete with "life-affirming views amid forgiving terrain".

There's a great video of Cumberland trail activist Larry Brock describing the trail and its economic impact. The work is still in progress, but the trail is already bringing positive economic benefits to the towns while presenting low obligations for maintenance and marketing. Seems pretty green/sustainable.

Maybe next summer, maybe 2011, the trail will be complete from McKeesport to Point State Park. Then we'll see more cyclists coming into Pittsburgh with loaded bags looking for lodging, carbs, and beer.


Current status is there's a trail in McKeesport that leads over the Riverton Bridge and then stops at the trainyards. In 2010, the trail, the gas company, and the railroads will complete the trail up to the Waterfront. The Holy Grail is the hope that there'll be an accomodation negotiated with Sandcastle by 2011.

I know great bicycle advocates in Pittsburgh who believe that their efforts are best spent on projects within the city proper- sharrows (that is, share-arrows) and bike lanes, signage, etc - and while those are very important, IMO the completion of the trail between Duquesne and the Hot Metal Bridge is going to be the event that moves downtown bicycling past the tipping point.

Completion of the trail will move out-of-town cyclists into the Duquesne-Southside-Station Square- Jail Trail - Downtown corridor. That will present a volume and a presence beyond that which local cyclists generate. It'll be a force-multiplier.

People will be coming into Pittsburgh to ride to DC, people will be coming from DC along the trail. Their economic impact will include bike accomodations, bike lockers, bicycle friendly hotels and restaurants, etc.

To a lesser extent, you'll see people flying into Pittsburgh with their bikes in bike-boxes and trying to ride out of the airport to a hotel near the trail complex - and then we'll see momentum for the Montour Trail's Enlow Road Connector.


I'm thinking our next sobriquet might be "Pittsburgh, the Copenhagen of Appalachia".
March 11, 2009

Mon Wharf Bike Trail Pittsburgh

Imagine this: you're bicycling into Pittsburgh from DC on the Great Allegheny Passage. You're riding north on the Southside Trail in Baldwin Borough, you've tried to plan a bike route to get to the fountain at the Point but however you try it, once you get to the Smithfield Street bridge the trail ends and you have to ride in streets with urban traffic for the last five blocks of your traffic-free ride from DC to Pittsburgh. You've ridden 352 miles on trails, except for those last five blocks in downtown Pittsburgh. And you're not riding a messenger's nimble fixie, you're riding a touring bike with heavy panniers loaded with gear.

That would be a mostly true report* now, but it's about to get a lot better. From the Post Gazette: Work begins on Mon Wharf trail link.
(My compliments to the artists, very nicely done)

I really appreciate the switchback ramp. It's very difficult to get a loaded touring bike up a staircase - there's a bridge in Harper's Ferry where you need to do that, and it's not very good.

This is welcome news. *There's also a trail section from McKeesport to Baldwin Borough that needs to be completed. That section is planned, approved, budgeted, and under way, with the exception of the Sandcastle property. The Sandcastle section seems likely to succeed, it'll be a negotiation between the owners and the County, probably mostly about liability.

I ride Pittsburgh-to-DC every few years with two friends, and I really think that once the Pittsburgh end of this trail is complete, you're going to see a lot of bicycle tourism. Also, once the PIT Airport to Montour Trail connector is built, you'll see people flying into PIT and riding to DC.